Reading Valdemar: Magic’s Pawn



Magic’s Pawn (The Last Herald-Mage #1)
by Mercedes Lackey
349 pages (mass market paperback)
first published June 1989 by DAW Books, Inc.

We first hear of Vanyel Ashkevron in the first few pages of Arrows of the Queen, Mercedes Lackey’s debut novel which had been published just two years earlier. In a snippet from a ballad popular in Talia’s day, we hear of the last stand of Vanyel, a legendary mage, and his poignant good-bye to his lover, Stefen.

But every legend has a beginning, and The Last Herald-Mage trilogy gives us that story. Vanyel does not begin his life as an incredibly powerful mage. In fact, when the story opens he seems to have very few talents aside from music and an excellent fashion sense. Neither of these traits is in his favor in his home on the border, where the men of his noble family fulfill every masculine image of his time and place- they are tall and brawny, blunt, have a healthy sex drive, and frown upon traditionally ‘feminine’ pursuits of education and music. With his good looks and love of music and books, Vanyel is an outcast in his family. His father neglects him in favor of his brawny younger brother, and for all the fluttering attentions his mother gives him, she isn’t much more helpful. Vanyel is different, and he doesn’t know why. He puts on an air of indifference to keep from feeling hurt by his family’s treatment, which makes them see him as a snob.

When his father has finally had enough and sends Vanyel to the faraway capital city of Haven to be instructed by his ill-tempered aunt Savil, Vanyel’s despair deepens. He discovers that, compared to his fellow students, he is almost ignorant, and his dreams of becoming a Bard are utterly dashed. What’s worse, is that he feels a strange attraction to one of Savil’s students, a beautiful young man named Tylendel.

Things come to a head when Vanyel realizes that men can actually be attracted to men and that he is falling head over heels for Tylendel, who returns the feeling.

As Vanyel has been emotionally abused and neglected for so long, his relationship with Tylendel quickly becomes co-dependant, which leads to tragedy when Tylendel’s family is attacked. Thanks to ill-advised magical manipulations, Vanyel’s latent magical gifts are blasted open, creating a powerful young mage with no control over his many new Gifts. Will Vanyel learn how to control his powers before he destroys himself and those around him?

I could write about how Magic’s Price is as entertaining now as it was when I first read it more than twenty years ago. Or, I could discuss how Mercedes Lackey’s writing improved from Arrow’s Fall, showcasing her growing skills of character development, pacing, and plot. But I’m not going to. Magic’s Price, and indeed the whole of the Last Herald-Mage trilogy has a special place in my heart because of how it helped me grow as a person.

Let me take you back to the 1990s. Not so dreadfully long ago calendar-wise, but eons ago when it comes to representation of the LGBTQIA community. When I was growing up in my little town on the prairie, it was still possible for parents and authority figures to keep things entirely hidden from their kids. There were no gay characters in middle-grade or YA books, on kids’ television (or really, on television in general). The internet was not in every home, and it was nearly impossible to find anything before Google came along. We had heard of AIDS in my school, but not how it devastated the gay community. There were ‘Defense of Marriage Acts’ being discussed across the country and ‘Don’t Ask Don’t Tell’ in the military. Until a little show called Will & Grace came along, there were virtually no gay characters in any pop culture venues I came across, and I never watced Will & Grace. So there were no positive LGBTQIA characters in any of the books I read. Mainstream publishers seemed to be doing their best to keep it that way.

Enter Mercedes Lackey. With pretty white horses on the cover and talk of magic in the synopsis, Lackey’s Valdemar books passed under the radar of parents and librarians who might otherwise have vetoed the purchase of the books. Since they didn’t know what the characters were all about, teens who might never have seen a positive representation of a gay character before got Vanyel, a misfit teenager, possibly like themselves, who felt unloved and could not figure out why he was different from everyone else around him. Once he meets Tylendel, however, he realizes that love can be different from what he’s always been told it was.

For some young readers, this was a revelation and helped to explain the feelings they were having, but could not explain. For some like me, Vanyel and his struggles put a human face on an idea that had been all but demonized in the media of the time. Because Vanyel is such a relatable and flawed character who is good at his core, I had someone to counter the negative stereotypes I had been given. And so, when a friend came out to me in high school, I was able to take a step back, realize that they were still the funny and friendly person I’d known before, and continue a rewarding friendship that lasted for years.

That is the power of quality representation. Fiction has the ability to open our minds to new ways of thinking and increases our empathy. When we encounter characters different from ourselves in books, we can get into their heads, see their reasoning and their perspectives, and potentially change our minds.



5 thoughts on “Reading Valdemar: Magic’s Pawn

  1. Oh, Kim, I love this post and am near tears. Not only am I so glad that you’re on this crazy journey with Jackie and me, but you always help me see each novel differently and more widely. At my high school (1999-2003), there were several out students, but I didn’t know much of what that meant to me beyond that. Then, one day, I learned that my art class friend Ashley, who was bi, was being picked on by some guy named Evan. Then I realized she meant the Evan I was friends with in French class. I remember thinking that I need to imitate my older brother, who could stop you dead in your tracks with one word and a scary serious face, and I did. I approached him, asked about Ashley, conjured that face, and simply said, “DON’T.” He actually went on to apologize to her, and I knew in that moment, without a doubt, I had done something that scared me and that was good. It was pivotal. I’m not sure I could have done that without Mercedes Lackey normalizing the LGBT+ community. She never stereotypes, and the more I read her, the more those stereotypes get pushed to the back of my mind.

  2. There were so few people trying to normalize LGBTQIA people in the 1990s. I am so glad I found these books to help me realize that my perceptions were so skewed! And good on you for sticking up for your friend! A lot of people wouldn’t have had the guts to do it.

  3. Wow– what a powerful post, Kim! You’re right, representation matters. And exposure to that representation is critical. I’m so glad that you were able to find Lackey at a time when it mattered in your life and you connected to the message she shared in your experiences. This is one of the amazing powers of reading and why I love it so very much.

    I appreciate that you call out, well, the other major ways in which this book can be explored. Yes, Lackey’s writing improved a lot. Yes, this is a highly entertaining books. But it’s the LGBTQA+ issues which are brought to the fore that overshadow all the rest. Even today, I don’t know if I could name 5 fantasy novels with LGBTQA issues present and accepted in such a seamless way. There’s something about Lackey’s writing which makes all this 100% natural and normal.

    Also: “In fact, when the story opens he seems to have very few talents aside from music and an excellent fashion sense.” This line? I did a spit take. It’s perfect.

  4. Representation definitely matters, and GOOD representation matters most. Vanyel is a rounded character whose sexuality is just one part of his life. He learned to be a good person in general, not just that he was gay and what a healthy relationship was.

    I think LGBTQIA issues are present in a lot more SFF novels than people think. It’s just that a lot of it was written in the 20th century, and so younger readers think they’re ‘old’ and have nothing to add. That’s not true, of course, but it seems difficult to get the kids to read something more than a couple of years old.

    *lol* Glad to make you laugh! I hope no damage was done to your computer or phone!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s