Book Review: Wicked Saints



Wicked Saints (Something Dark and Holy #1)
by Emily A. Duncan
YA Fantasy
400 pages
Expected publication date: April 2, 2019, by Wednesday Books


Anyone who has done more than a cursory study of the life of Joan of Arc will have some understanding of her essential strangeness. Joan, an illiterate teenaged peasant with visions of angels somehow made it into the French royal court, and then somehow met the heir to the throne, who then, for unknown/mystical reasons, sent this girl to war– which the French then started to win against superior English forces. Joan went on to lead the French army to numerous victories until she was betrayed by her king and burned as a witch by the English. Her biography is less “I’m not like other girls”, and closer to “I’m not like other human beings”. With her debut novel, Wicked Saints, Emily A. Duncan attempts to create a Joan-like figure in Nadezhda Lapteva, or Nadya, a teenaged peasant girl who has spent her life in a monastery. Her great gift comes from the fact that when she speaks to the gods, they talk back, granting her divine powers based upon the trait of the god she calls to.

This is a useful ability given that she is among the last clerics of her home country, Kalyazin, which is fighting a century-long war against the neighboring country of Tranavia, where blood mages rule. These blood mages are branded as heretics in Kalyazin, but the Tranavians’ lack of faith has not stopped them from making headway in the war. The Tranavian army is led by the crown prince, nineteen-year-old  Serefin Maleski, a powerful blood mage tasked with winning the war and wiping out any of Kalyazin’s remaining clerics. As the story opens, Serefin’s forces attack Nadya’s monastery forcing her to leave behind her best friend and everything she has ever known. During her headlong flight into the forest, Nadya meets an enemy blood mage, Malachiasz Czechowicz, who is also fleeing from the Tranavians, but for very different reasons. Together, Nadya and Malachiasz decide to sneak into Tranavia and assassinate its king, thereby ending the war. At the same time, Serefin is summoned home to participate in the Rawalyk, a Travanian tradition designed to find the prince a suitable bride. Magic, faith, and treachery collide in a divine battle that will determine the futures of Kalyazin and Tranavia.

As a concept, Wicked Saints is compelling. What does war do to young leaders? How does it affect those who the world sees as monstrous? What role should the faithful play in war? Add in a Gothic tone with its attendant dark setting and brooding atmosphere, and you should have a strong story on your hands. Unfortunately, Wicked Saints retreads a  literary ground that has long since been tramped down to mud and fails to stand up to basic questions regarding its own world. Case in point, “In a land where gods are real and active, what does it mean when a heretic army is victorious?”. I asked myself this question early on, and so predicted a major plot twist from the ending. And while Nadya is billed as a ‘Gothic Joan of Arc’, she has none of her real-world predecessor’s strangeness or ability to inspire armies. Instead, Nadya is set to be yet another entry in a long line of bland Strong Female Characters who can’t help but fall in love with the Bad Boy With a Dark Past, and who is willing to forgive the war criminals she associates with simply because they have a sad past and a cute haircut.

The world, too, is underdeveloped, as though Duncan was relying on the setting’s Polish roots and the book’s description as “Gothic” to complete the exposition for her. Sadly, that’s not enough to describe a world, and we’re told little more than that it is cold and wooded. We are given churches and cathedrals and little sense of what they look like, and dangerous lands the characters easily cross within a day or two. The morose atmosphere and realism edged by a looming supernatural threat- hallmarks of Gothic literature- are barely evident. But to give Duncan credit where credit is due, there are moments of truly creepy imagery. These are often spoiled in the next paragraph by stilted dialogue or yet another action scene designed to make the book action-packed without adding significantly to the story.

It’s a shame. Wicked Saints promised to be an incredible tale of dark and divine magics striving against each other in an eerie world of gloomy, wintry cathedrals. But in the end, it is little more than processed story product wrapped in a shiny black veneer. And so I’m left with this final impression: Wicked Saints– neither wicked nor saints. Discuss.



Thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for providing me with a free eBook in exchange for an honest review. This did not influence my opinion in any way.


11 thoughts on “Book Review: Wicked Saints

  1. Great review. The concept interested me but I lost interest as I read. I agree with you about Nadya being quite bland. I also wasn’t convinced about the gods because they aren’t approached by Nadya or anyone else with any sort of reverence. The strike me more as spirits able to fulfill Nadya’s requests. But I didn’t finish the story so maybe this changes later on.

  2. I love this line in your review: Her biography is less “I’m not like other girls”, and closer to “I’m not like other human beings”.

    I love it because I’m very worn out with the trope that for a girl or woman to have value, she must be completely different from other girls. I’m left wondering, what’s wrong with girls that girls don’t wan to be like, well, girls! I’m sure it goes back further, but I blame characters like Katniss Everdeen. I think people really became hip to the “cool girl” trope when the main character in Gone Girl had a whole paragraph dissecting what a “cool girl” really is.

  3. I had forgotten the ‘cool girl’ dissection in Gone Girl until you mentioned it! Though I don’t know that Nadya is meant to be a ‘cool girl’. But with her religious inclinations, it felt like she was meant to come off as this otherworldly warrior, but had her feet planted too firmly on the ground to pull it off. But yeah, the ‘cool girl’ in YA fantasy drives me a bit nuts, too.

  4. Pingback: State of the ARC, March 2019 | Traveling in Books

  5. Pingback: March Summary and April Preview | Traveling in Books

  6. Just finished this book a couple of days ago, and all I have to say is YAAAAS. I thought the book was a major disappointment that showcased very mediocre and bland writing.

  7. Definitely. Apparently, Duncan was writing it while finishing graduate school. I wish she had waited until she was done with her degree, and THEN written her book. I’m sure it would have been a lot better if Duncan had dedicated real time to it instead of dashing it off in her spare moments.

  8. Pingback: 2019 Year in Review | Traveling in Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s