Book Review: Knife Children


Knife Children (The Sharing Knife #4.5)
by Lois McMaster Bujold
148 pages
Expected publication date February 29, 2020, by Subterranean Press


The fantasy genre normally concerns itself with grand events. The scrappy band of heroes must defeat the Evil Lord who is trying to take over the world; the anti-hero must defeat the even worse villain before said villain destroys the city; the Chosen One must destroy the MacGuffin before the Dark Lord destroys all freedom. That sort of thing. What is often left out are the small domestic matters that would naturally take up the majority of the characters’ lives. Few authors take up these domestic matters as the focus of their stories, and even fewer do it well. Throughout her long career, multiple Hugo Award-winning author Lois McMaster Bujold has often focused on domestic matters, cutting into the complicated emotions that turn seemingly simple matters into complicated and dramatic stories.

Knife Children tells the story of Barr Foxbrush, a magically gifted Lakewalker returning home after patrolling the distant wilderness of Luthalia against the destructive creatures known as malices. Just a few days’ ride from home, he decides to stop by the Mason family’s home to see how they are doing. Specifically, he is there to check in on fourteen-year-old Lily, who is Barr’s daughter thanks to a youthful indiscretion. After Barr’s departure fifteen years earlier, Lily’s mother Belle quickly married a farmer, told him that Lily was his daughter, and has held the secret in all these years. But when Lily runs away after a tragedy, Barr must find her and own up to his past mistakes before they can move on into the future.

“He prudently waited until she had some food inboard before digging out and handing across Fid’s letter. He thought she’d have been happier if he’d offered her a rattlesnake, but she did take it, and, after biting her lip, ripped it open, scattering the carefully reaffixed sealing wax. She peered at the crabbed scrawl in the growing twilight, mouth moving as she sounded out the words. When she finished, she squeezed the letter into a tight ball and threw it hard onto the fire. Barr winced as it flared up, feeling for Fid.”


One of Bujold’s great strengths as a writer is her ability to create fully rounded characters who have great flaws as well as great strengths, but who are willing to grow as they move through their lives. Barr and Lily are no different in Knife Children. Though he spent his youth pulling pranks and giving his elders endless headaches, Barr has matured since then, becoming a responsible man who understands his duties to his family and his people. But he still has his flaws: he doesn’t want to admit to his past relationship with Belle, a farmer woman, even though withholding the truth does more harm than good.

Lily, on the other hand, is struggling under the weight of a harsh accusation and the trials of adolescence. She’s a headstrong young woman who is suspicious of the motives of her elders, but she’s also lonely and longing for praise and friendship.

Barr and Lily’s fraught relationship drives this story forward, not action or the dangers that lurk throughout the world they inhabit. Their conflict is all this novella needs to become a compelling story.

The worldbuilding in Knife Children is subtle, and while some of it is done in conversations– Lily doesn’t understand the Lakewalker culture, so he must explain parts of it to her– the rest is done through interactions between family and community, in the characters’ opinions of each other and of other cultural groups, and even through the dialogue and the way Barr and the others describe things. The Lakewalkers and their farmer counterparts live in a rough world filled with danger. Their speech, attitudes, and preconceptions show the reader the reality of it.

Lois McMaster Bujold was recently awarded the Damon Knight Memorial Grand Master Award, an honor given to just thirty-six authors in the award’s forty-five-year history. She has written everything from sweeping space operas to small-scale domestic dramas set in fantasy worlds. What she brings to all her stories is a realistic presentation of people, with all their flaws and skills, who are doing their best to make their worlds a little bit better. With Knife Children, Bujold has given us yet another brilliant and heartfelt story.

6 thoughts on “Book Review: Knife Children

  1. I don’t know how I’ve never heard of Lois McMaster Bujold considering I love fantasy and science fiction so much. This woman is so prolific! I find most of the fantasy and sci-fi I read comes from recommendations and book clubs. I really need to start doing some general research. Goodness.

    This book sounds so much fun– I do love exploring domestic life over grand adventures, sometimes. This is why my favorite genre is magical realism. This genre most often explore the mundane with fantastic elements. Have you read other books in The Shearing Knife? Will you be reading more?

  2. Lois McMaster Bujold is, like a lot of SFF writers with long careers, someone who flies under the radar. I kind of suspect that it might come from the fact that she usually publishes with small presses and isn’t a charismatic young thing who does publicity tours and signings… But she has been writing amazing books that explore humanity in all its forms, and her many, many awards are well-earned.

    I read the first Sharing Knife book years ago, and it didn’t resonate with me the way her other books did, so I didn’t continue it. I might give it another shot, though. I’ve changed a lot since I read it.

  3. It’s really amazing how books change for us as we grow and change. One of my favorite reviews I ever wrote was for The Giver. It’s a reflection on all the different times I read the book throughout my life and how it impacted me differently each time (Shameless plug! The Giver)
    I hope that if you give it another shot you’ll let me know if your perspective has changed. People are so amazing.

  4. Pingback: State of the ARC: February 2020 | Traveling in Books

  5. Preach. So many books, so little time. If I wasn’t so much of an extrovert, I’d definitely try to make a career about of book blogging just so I can read more. Or divorce my husband and marry someone super rich so I can just read all day without making money.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s